With so many brands and models to choose from, it can be overwhelming to know where to start. In this comparison and brand analysis, we’ll take a closer look at Winnebago and Forest River, two popular RV brands on the market today, and help you make an informed decision about which one is the right fit for you.
Key Takeaways:
The cost is the primary difference between Winnebago and Forest River RVs. Typically, Winnebago RVs are pricier, but they retain their value because they are from a reputable brand in the RV industry. In contrast, Forest River RVs are a great choice for those on a tight budget.
Please keep reading to delve deeper into a detailed comparison of both brands, including their maintenance requirements, construction quality, cost, and customer support.
Who Owns Winnebago?
Winnebago, which was founded in Forest City, Iowa in 1958, has emerged as a leading manufacturer of recreational vehicles. Over time, the company expanded its portfolio to include not just motorhomes, but also travel trailers.
In addition, Winnebago is publicly traded, allowing investors to purchase its shares on the stock market. As a parent company, Winnebago oversees several well-known RV brands, including Newmar, and Grand Design.
Recommended Read:
If you have ever considered paying cash for an RV thinking you might save some money, sorry to say that is not always the case. I highly recommend reading the following article first.
Who Owns Forest River?
Forest River is owned by Berkshire Hathaway, which is a multinational holding company led by Warren Buffett. Forest River was founded in 1996 and is headquartered in Elkhart, Indiana, USA. As a parent brand, Forest River owns several popular RV brands, including Coachmen, Dynamax, East to West, and others.
RV Types Offered By Both RV Brands
| RV Type: | Winnebago: | Forest River: |
| Motorized | Class A | Class A |
| Motorized | Class C | Class C |
| Non-Motorized | Travel Trailers | Toy Haulers |
| Non-Motorized | Fifth Wheels | |
| Non-Motorized | Travel Trailers | |
| Non-Motorized | Destination Trailers | |
| Non-Motorized | Camping Trailers | |
| Motorized | Camper Vans | |
| Motorized | Accessibility Enhanced |
Winnebago vs. Forest River: Complete Brand Comparison
| Comparison Points: | Winnebago: | Forest River: |
| Founded | 1958 | 1996 |
| Company Support | Average | Sub-Par |
| Maintenance | Average | Average |
| Build Quality And Design | Average | Average |
| Cost | More | Less |
Maintenance And Problems: Winnebago vs. Forest River
When considering purchasing a recreational vehicle from either Winnebago or Forest River, it’s important to take into account potential maintenance concerns and problems.
Despite Winnebago’s five-decade-long prominence in the RV industry, the brand has faced a range of issues over the years. For instance, the 2004 Winnebago Sightseer has been associated with engine malfunction and brake piston seizing, among other problems.
Recommended Read:
On the surface, the RV industry has many brands to choose from, but when looking deeper, most RV brands in the market are owned by three large companies. Check out our article below to see which brands are under the same umbrella.
Similarly, owners of the popular Micro Minnie trailer model have experienced issues like axle installation errors and a lack of an emergency exit window in the bedroom of the 2020 models.
Meanwhile, Forest River RV is not exempt from maintenance and problem issues either. Some common concerns include poor finishing, slide-out malfunctions, and subpar appliances.
Overall, when it comes to both Winnebago and Forest River RVs, it’s important to anticipate some level of maintenance and problem-related challenges.
Build Quality: Winnebago vs. Forest River
Winnebago RVs are generally considered to be decent in terms of build quality, although not the best on the market. While maintenance may be required, this is true for any RV brand.
On the other hand, Forest River RVs have received mixed reviews regarding their build quality. While some buyers have experienced minimal issues with their units, others have had persistent problems from day one.
Many of the complaints about Forest River RVs are specific to particular parts or issues. Overall, it appears that Forest River RVs offer average build quality for their price point, unless you opt for one of their premium lines.
In short, Winnebago RVs have a decent build quality, while Forest River RVs offer average build quality for their price point, with some mixed reviews and persistent issues reported by some buyers. Regardless of the brand you choose, it’s important to expect some level of maintenance and potential problems with any RV.
Customer Support: Winnebago vs. Forest River
The perception of Winnebago RV customers regarding the quality of the company’s customer service is diverse. Nevertheless, some customers have raised concerns about the service’s sluggishness and lack of effectiveness. Furthermore, a small number of buyers have indicated that the Winnebago owner’s manuals are excessively general and not particularly helpful.
In general, Forest River RV doesn’t have a very good reputation among customers. Repeatedly delayed repairs have been cited as complaints from customers. Although Forest River provides warranty services, several customers have complained about access issues and inadequate help.
Cost: Winnebago vs. Forest River
When comparing the prices of a used 2019 Class C Forest River RV and a used 2019 Class C Winnebago RV, it is apparent that the Winnebago RV is more expensive, with a cost of over $100K.
On the other hand, the Forest River RV is priced at approximately $79K. However, it’s important to note that the cost of an RV can be influenced by a variety of factors, such as its age, condition, features, and location.
Pros and Cons Of Winnebago
| Pros | Cons |
| Trusted Brand | Average Build Quality |
| RVs Hold Their Value Overtime |
Pros and Cons of Forest River
| Pros | Cons |
| Affordable RVs | Not Too Impressive Customer Service |
| Wide Floor Plans And Model Variety |
Related Read: Winnebago vs. Entegra: Comparison & Brand Analysis
What Do Redditors Think About Winnebago And Forest River?
The opinions of Reddit users regarding Winnebago RVs are varied. Some are content with the clever design features and appropriate size that cater to their family’s needs, while others have expressed discontent with the RVs’ build quality and issues arising from inferior materials.
Despite the conflicting feedback, a few users have shared positive experiences with previous Winnebago models, highlighting their sturdiness and satisfactory construction quality.
Nevertheless, the majority of users generally acknowledge that owning an RV necessitates regular upkeep and repairs, regardless of the brand.
The general consensus of what Reddit users think about Forest River RVs is that it’s a mixed bag. While some users have experienced quality craftsmanship and attention to detail, others have reported poor workmanship, cheap materials, and several issues with their Forest River RVs.
[Sources: Reddit Posts – 1, 2, 3]
Final Verdict – Which Brand Is Better For You?
If you are looking for an RV from a trusted brand and the one holds its value, Winnebago is the right choice for you. However, if you have a tight budget and prefer a variety of floor plans, Forest River RV is the right pick for you.
Ultimately, the decision depends on your personal preferences and priorities, as both brands have their strengths and weaknesses.
Read Next: Winnebago vs. Coachmen: Brand Analysis & Build Overview